13 February 2020
We have achieved several changes to the project since 2010 but continue to be concerned about its noise impacts on many waterways and its damaging effects on some canal restoration schemes.
We celebrated a major victory in 2014 when we persuaded the Government to change the route of the Handsacre Link spur near Lichfield to avoid two crossings of the Trent & Mersey Canal which would have seriously damaged the environment, tranquillity and heritage of the canal around Woodend Lock above Fradley Junction.
Working in conjunction with Lichfield & Hatherton Canals Restoration Trust, Lichfield Cruising Club and Canal & River Trust, we also secured assurances that HS2 will build a canal diversion and fund a replacement moorings basin at Cappers Lane in Lichfield when the bridge there is demolished for an HS2 viaduct.
Other changes we have campaigned for include lowering the height of the viaducts around Kings Bromley, additional noise fencing at Fradley and Great Haywood, and improvements to the design of the viaduct over the Birmingham and Fazeley Canal at Curdworth.
The Government’s decision is to proceed with Phase 1 and Phase 2a of HS2, from London to Birmingham and via Fradley to Crewe, although it is not yet clear if this includes the Handsacre Link. The decision was based on the Oakervee Review report which clearly recommends removing this connection to the West Coast Mainline which would be costly to build and of limited use. Its route still passes close to the canal and the diversion of Wood End Lane there will be intrusive so we support its deletion from the project.
On Phase 1, we remain particularly concerned about the noise impact on the tranquil summit section of the Oxford Canal near Wormleighton.
Phase 2a will cross the Trent & Mersey Canal at Great Haywood on a viaduct right alongside the marina and we are represented on an advisory group which has produced a Design Principles document to help mitigate its construction and operational impacts. The group has also obtained funding from HS2 for environmental enhancement works that are likely to include towpath improvements.
Phase 2b of HS2 includes Crewe to Manchester and Wigan and the eastern leg from Birmingham to Leeds and affects at least 16 waterways in 22 locations. We have major concerns about its impacts on the Trent & Mersey Canal north of Middlewich, the Ashby Canal restoration at Measham, the Erewash Canal at Sandiacre, and the Chesterfield Canal restoration at Staveley. The Government has said this phase will proceed but only after a further review to better integrate it with other rail improvements in the North and Midlands.
Phil Sharpe, IWA Lichfield Branch Chairman and a member of IWA’s Planning Advisory Panel, said “Whilst many of these issues have affected the Lichfield area, IWA has also campaigned nationally by responding to the many consultations, attending exhibitions, meeting HS2 engineers and liaising with construction contractors. IWA has petitioned Parliament three times and given evidence to both House of Commons and Lords Select Committees on a range of issues including the need for better noise protection at all the locations where HS2 crosses or runs close to waterways.
“Keeping up with HS2 by reading all the reports and examining all the relevant plans has been a massive undertaking but we will continue to engage with all the HS2 public consultations and to campaign for better protection for the precious environment of our navigable and restorable waterways.”
Find out more about our HS2 campaign.